Majestic: the wbs bring that low at 60cm is a major turnoff. Try the dorsal at 9wb range 60 like the apoc and prow 2 lances.
Claymore: compare it to the Iconoclast. I think this could be made into a counterpart to it. Also, I think calling it something other than corvette would be good. I would consult andrewchristlieb's write-up for the corvette stuff. ![Smiley :)](http://www.specialist-arms.com/forum/Smileys/default/smiley.gif)
Turbulent: in would like to see some editing of the weapons to change it from a beefed up sword. Maybe make it have the SM nova weaponry with both being F/L/R?
Firedagger: here we go again..... The fleet defense turrets is a highly hot button issue around here. Personally, I have no problem with it.
I was warry about Dorsal WB and making the Majestic too diverse. Your design is sound in principle though. What does everyone else think?
Claymore is a Corvette directly out of the Battlefleet Koronus book- changing the name not so much an option as a result. It looks smaller than a falcion and has a small armament. If his idea of a corvette is a ship that bridges the gap between ordnance and escorts, there is something like that coming based off grimdark bits patrol torpedo boat squadron.
http://www.shapeways.com/model/680962/bfg-patrol-torpedo-boat-squadron-x3.html?li=productBox-search As compared to the Iconoclast, I think it is right on, as the Iconoclast is 30cm but is 4+, whereas this is 25cm but 5+. I'll loose a turret too to make it even.
The Turbulent is also directly out of BF Koronus. It unfortunately has no lance on it in that.
As for the firedagger and fleet defence turret, I don't think it matters if people hate the idea of them or not. This is a compendium of UNOFFICIAL ships, and as such are used
1- ONLY with opponents permission
2- are intended for Fun and/or Fluffy use in friendly games and/or unique scenarios
I would see the point in arguing over them if they were being worked into an official list, but since this is an unofficial fan work for uncompetitive friendly use, I think they are fine and it should be allowed for players to use it if they want to.