I'm the dissenter!
Really, I gave my opinion in the other thread. I think they should be +1, +2 etc instead of static values. Despite what we can infer from the BBB that horizon's post on the other thread detailed, I don't think we should ever, EVER pay for what could easily become a downgrade (more likely for chaos, I know). The other thing is the Emperor. A small difference, I guess, but given it's popularity...
If a fleet has an Emperor battleship in it, the fleet commander is going to be on it. But with the Emperor's special rules, that will more often than not end up being on par, or a downgrade! Leading you to place your commander on another ship.
That's my biggest problem, but I also think subs should also be 25pts instead of 30, and RRs should be 25pts, for two reasons. 1, 50 fits into fleets generally more easily than 45. 2, the RR itself may be limited, but the tactical bonus it gives to your fleet reroll(s) is huge! Now you can use it more aggressively because your sub in your dictator has got that squadron covered for rerolls.
As an aside, I also agree with Talos that the basic leader at some point values should be free (E.g. 50pt leader at 750, 75pt leader at 1500 etc), with puchaseable ld and RR upgrades...I play with plastic ships, not imginary people on the ships. Leave that for DnD/Rogue Trader.